The Data Is In: Small Businesses Using AI Are More Optimistic About Hiring and Growth
A Federal Reserve Bank survey of 5,248 US small businesses found that AI adopters have more than twice the employment optimism of non-adopters. 33 percentage points net expectation of hiring growth vs 15 for non-users. A 27-point gap on revenue optimism: 48 vs 21. These aren’t marginal differences, they represent a meaningful split in how owners who use AI see their near-term future.
The New York Fed published the analysis in October 2026, drawing on the 2025 Small Business Credit Survey (SBCS). Researchers Will Aarons and Asani Sarkar spent time ruling out the obvious counterarguments before concluding the data holds up.
What the numbers say
The survey covered employer firms across the US, fielded between September and November 2025. By that point, 46% of small businesses with at least one employee were using AI tools. Another 15% planned to adopt in the next twelve months. Among those already using AI, 63% said it was “somewhat or very important to production.” Half had integrated it partially or fully into their operations.
The headline employment figure, 33 vs 15 percentage points net optimism, survives some serious statistical scrutiny. The researchers controlled for age of owner, firm size, profitability, location, and past employment changes. After all that, the gap between adopters and non-adopters narrowed but stayed positive, at 10 percentage points. On revenue expectations, the adjusted gap sits at 14 percentage points.
The most counterintuitive finding: the optimism gap is largest among businesses in weaker financial shape. Among owners who reported “fair or poor” current conditions, AI users had a 21-point hiring optimism advantage over non-users. For businesses already doing well, the advantage was 10 points. The researchers’ interpretation: AI may be helping struggling businesses overcome specific constraints, particularly technology-related operational problems, rather than simply reflecting the outlook of confident, well-resourced owners.
The alternative explanations don’t fully stick
You could argue that optimistic owners are just more likely to try new things, including AI. The NY Fed addressed this by using current financial condition as a proxy for optimism. If general positivity were driving both AI adoption and rosy forecasts, you’d expect the AI optimism premium to be strongest among owners already feeling good. Instead, it’s stronger among those feeling worse. That’s a difficult pattern to explain away.
You could also argue that businesses growing fast are naturally more likely to hire and to adopt AI as part of that expansion. The researchers controlled for past twelve-month employment and revenue changes. The gap persisted.
None of this proves causation. The NY Fed is careful to note that whether AI-adopting firms achieve the outcomes they expect is “a subject for future research.” What the data does show is a consistent, statistically significant association that survives the standard methodological challenges.
Where does Australia sit in this picture?
The SBCS is US data, so direct comparison requires some care. But local research points in a similar direction.
NAB’s SME research found that 40% of Australian SMEs using AI reported measurable benefits, productivity gains, time savings, and in some cases revenue lift. That aligns with the US pattern: adoption correlates with positive outcomes, not just positive attitudes.
The ABS hasn’t yet published business-level AI adoption data at the granularity of the SBCS, so a direct optimism-gap comparison isn’t possible. What we do have: consistent signals from multiple sources that AU businesses using AI tend to report better outcomes than those that aren’t. The gap between adopters and holdouts in AU appears real, even if the exact numbers differ from the US survey.
One structural difference worth noting: Australian small businesses operate in a higher-cost labour market with stronger employment regulations. If AI helps with hiring, by improving targeting, reducing admin in onboarding, or making a smaller team more productive, the benefit in AU may be felt more acutely than in comparable US businesses. That’s speculation, but it’s not unreasonable speculation.
Why the gap exists
The NY Fed’s data points to technology-related operational challenges as a key lever. Businesses that struggle with their website, social media, ecommerce, or cybersecurity, and are using AI, show a 16-point net revenue optimism advantage over AI users without those challenges. The implication: AI is helping some businesses deal with friction they couldn’t solve otherwise.
For AU small businesses, that friction is familiar. Staff shortages, skills gaps, the cost of specialist help. A business that previously couldn’t afford a full-time marketing coordinator, now has a set of AI tools doing some of that work. The SBCS data suggests that’s enough to shift expectations. Owners start seeing AI as something that solves real problems, worth integrating rather than just experimenting with.
The AI gap between enterprises and small businesses in AU is well-documented. Large firms have the budgets, the technical staff, and the risk tolerance to build bespoke AI infrastructure. Small businesses are working with off-the-shelf tools. The US data suggests that even at that level, AI tools, not AI investment, adoption changes how owners see their prospects.
What to make of it
Optimism is not the same as outcomes. The NY Fed is explicit about that. A business owner who uses ChatGPT for proposals and expects 20% revenue growth next year may not get it. Survey expectations notoriously diverge from results.
But expectation gaps this large, this persistent across controls, tell you something about who is seeing immediate value. The AU and US data points the same direction: businesses that have moved from curiosity to actual use are reporting, and now, expecting, better outcomes than those waiting on the sideline.
The question for AU holdouts isn’t whether the US data is perfectly transferable. It’s whether they have a clear account of what specifically they’re waiting for.
More hot takes: Hot Takes →
📬 The SmallBizAI Brief
One practical AI tip for Australian small business. Every Tuesday. Free.
Join business owners getting smarter about AI every week.
Sources
- NY Fed Liberty Street Economics: AI Adoption and Employment Expectations (October 2026)
- Federal Reserve Banks: 2026 Report on Employer Firms (2025 SBCS)
- NAB’s New AI Research: What 40% of Australian SMEs Using AI Actually Found
- The Pressure Is Real: How Australian Small Businesses Are Using AI to Turn It Into Progress
- The AI “Level Playing Field” Hasn’t Reached Australian Small Business






