Deputy vs Employment Hero vs Tanda: Which Is Best for Australian Hospitality and Retail?

Rostering, timesheets, and payroll are among the most time-consuming admin tasks for Australian small business owners: and getting them wrong carries real Fair Work risk. Deputy, Employment Hero, and Tanda (now Workforce.com) are the three platforms most commonly used by Australian businesses. Here’s an honest comparison.

The Short Answer

• Deputy: best for businesses where rostering and shift management are the priority (hospitality, retail, healthcare)
• Employment Hero: best for businesses that want an all-in-one HR, payroll, and rostering platform
• Tanda (Workforce.com): best for larger or more complex operations needing sophisticated award interpretation and workforce analytics

Deputy

What It Does Well

Deputy is an Australian-founded company (Sydney) and one of the most widely used rostering tools in the country. Its core strength is intuitive, fast roster building: you can drag and drop shifts, copy rosters week to week, and manage last-minute changes from your phone.

• Award interpretation. Deputy’s AI automatically calculates penalty rates, overtime, and allowances for Australian Modern Awards. This alone saves significant time and reduces compliance risk.
• Employee app: staff can view rosters, clock in/out, swap shifts, and request leave from their phone
• Integrations: connects with Xero, MYOB, QuickBooks, and most POS systems
• Free tier: limited but usable for very small teams

Limitations

• HR features are basic. Deputy is rostering-first, not an HR platform
• Payroll requires integration with a separate accounting tool
• Reporting is functional but not as deep as Tanda

Pricing (AUD, 2026)

From approximately $4.50 per user/month for scheduling only, up to $9+ for the full suite. Free trial available.

Best for: Cafés, restaurants, retail, aged care, cleaning businesses: anywhere that roster management is the core need.

Employment Hero

What It Does Well

Employment Hero is also Australian-founded (Sydney) and has grown into a full HR, payroll, and workforce management platform. If you want one system to handle everything from hiring to payslips, Employment Hero is the strongest contender.

• End-to-end HR: contracts, onboarding, leave management, performance reviews, offboarding: all in one platform
• Built-in payroll. Employment Hero’s payroll engine handles STP Phase 2, superannuation, and Australian award rates natively (no integration required)
• AI features. AI job ad writing, AI-assisted onboarding, and Smart Match for recruitment
• Compliance templates: pre-built employment contracts and HR policies for Australian law

Limitations

• Rostering is functional but less polished than Deputy for complex shift-based businesses
• Can feel like a lot of platform if you only need basic rostering
• Pricing scales up as you add modules

Pricing (AUD, 2026)

HR platform from approximately $8 per employee/month. Payroll is an additional module. Free tier available for very small teams.

Best for: Growing businesses (5–200 staff) that want to consolidate HR admin. Professional services, healthcare, tech, and any business hiring regularly.

Tanda (Workforce.com)

What It Does Well

Tanda (now rebranded as Workforce.com internationally) was founded in Brisbane and has built one of the most sophisticated award interpretation engines in Australia. It’s particularly strong for businesses with complex rosters and large casual workforces.

• Award interpretation: widely regarded as the most accurate and comprehensive in the market for complex awards (retail, hospitality, healthcare)
• Workforce analytics: labour cost forecasting, demand-based rostering, and wage budget management are genuinely powerful
• Compliance confidence: particularly strong for businesses managing multiple awards or states
• Integrations: connects with major POS systems and accounting platforms

Limitations

• Steeper learning curve than Deputy
• Better suited to mid-size operations than micro businesses
• Less comprehensive on the HR side compared to Employment Hero

Pricing (AUD, 2026)

From approximately $4 per user/month. Enterprise pricing for larger teams. Free trial available.

Best for: Retailers, hospitality groups, healthcare providers, and any business with 20+ staff managing complex awards.

Head-to-Head Summary

Which Should You Choose?

• Running a café, restaurant, or retail shop? Start with Deputy. It’s purpose-built for this and the award automation is excellent.
• Growing a professional services or healthcare business? Employment Hero gives you HR depth you’ll actually use.
• Managing 20+ staff across multiple awards or locations? Tanda’s analytics and award engine justify the learning curve.
• Want to consolidate HR and payroll into one tool? Employment Hero is the only one of the three with a fully integrated payroll engine.

All three offer free trials: the best approach is to test the one that matches your primary need before committing.

Sources and Further Reading

• Deputy. Official Website
• Employment Hero. Official Website
• Workforce.com (Tanda). Official Website
• Fair Work Ombudsman. Award and Pay Tools
• ATO. Single Touch Payroll Phase 2

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Deputy or Tanda better for Australian award compliance?

Tanda (Workforce.com) has stronger award interpretation features, particularly for businesses covered by complex Modern Awards in hospitality, retail, and aged care. Deputy handles award compliance well but Tanda’s built-in award library and automatic rate calculations are more comprehensive for large casual workforces.

Does Employment Hero replace Xero or MYOB?

No. Employment Hero handles HR and payroll but integrates with Xero and MYOB rather than replacing them. Your accounting software handles financial reporting and tax; Employment Hero handles the HR layer. The two work together.

What rostering app do most Australian small businesses use?

Deputy is the most widely used rostering app among Australian small businesses, particularly in hospitality and retail. It has the largest Australian market share and integrates with most major POS and payroll systems. Tanda is a strong second, especially popular for businesses with large hourly workforces.

Our Verdict (2026)

Deputy is the default choice for most Australian small businesses — it’s the most widely used, integrates with everything, and works well for hospitality, retail, and healthcare. If you’re running shifts and need something that just works, start here.

Employment Hero wins if you want to consolidate HR, payroll, and rostering under one roof. The higher price is justified if you’re currently paying for multiple tools separately.

Tanda (Workforce.com) is the pick for businesses with complex Modern Award obligations — aged care, hospitality groups, large casual workforces. Its award interpretation engine is the most thorough of the three.

All three offer free trials. Most businesses find their answer within the first two weeks.

📊 Compare AI tools side by side | 💼 Free resources & AI prompt packs

Looking for more comparisons? Browse all our Best-Of guides for Australian small business →