Stripe vs Square vs Tyro: Best Payment Platform for Australian Small Business (2026)

Choosing the right payment platform can save: or cost: an Australian small business thousands of dollars a year. Stripe, Square, and Tyro are the three most popular options in 2026, but they’re built for very different businesses.

This guide breaks down fees, features, and fit so you can pick the right one without the headache.

Quick Verdict

Stripe: Best for Online-First Businesses

Stripe is the global leader in online payment processing, and it’s a dominant choice for Australian e-commerce stores, SaaS businesses, and anyone selling primarily online.

Pricing

• Online card payments: 1.7% + A$0.30 per transaction
• In-person card payments: 1.7% per transaction
• International cards: +1.5% surcharge
• Currency conversion: +2% surcharge
• No monthly fees on standard plan

What Stripe Does Well

• Developer-friendly API: if you have a developer, Stripe can do almost anything
• Subscription billing: best-in-class recurring payments for subscription businesses
• 1,000+ integrations. Shopify, WooCommerce, Xero, MYOB, Zapier, and more
• Stripe Radar: built-in AI fraud detection included at no extra cost
• Invoicing: send and collect invoices directly through Stripe
• Multi-currency: accept payments in 135+ currencies

Where Stripe Falls Short

• In-person hardware. Stripe Terminal is available in Australia but has limited hardware options compared to Square or Tyro
• Support: no phone support on standard plan; email and chat only
• Not built for hospitality: no integrated POS system with table management or ordering

Best For

E-commerce stores, SaaS companies, subscription businesses, developers building custom payment flows, and any business doing significant online volume.

Square: Best for Retail and Hospitality

Square entered Australia in 2016 and has built a loyal base of cafés, restaurants, market stalls, and small retailers. Its free POS software plus affordable hardware is hard to beat for businesses that sell face-to-face.

Pricing

• In-person card payments: 1.6% per transaction
• Online payments: 1.9% + A$0.10 per transaction (via Square Online)
• Manually keyed transactions: 2.2%
• Square Reader: A$59 (tap & chip)
• Square Terminal: A$399 (standalone terminal with receipt printer)
• Square Register: A$1,099 (full POS setup)
• No monthly fees on free plan (paid plans from A$29/month add more features)

What Square Does Well

• Free POS software: inventory, staff management, sales reports included at no cost
• Hospitality tools. Square for Restaurants includes table management, floor plans, order routing
• Offline mode: keeps taking payments even when internet drops
• Ecosystem depth. Square Payroll, Square Appointments, Square Loyalty all integrate natively
• Simple flat-rate pricing: no surprises, easy to forecast costs

Where Square Falls Short

• Online payments cost more than Stripe (1.9% + 10¢ vs Stripe’s 1.7% + 30¢. Stripe wins on larger transactions)
• Account stability issues. Square has been known to freeze accounts without notice; keep a backup payment method
• No phone support unless on a paid plan
• Limited for complex e-commerce. Square Online is functional but not as powerful as Shopify + Stripe

Best For

Cafés, restaurants, market vendors, pop-up shops, salons, and any business that needs solid in-person payments with a free POS system.

Tyro: Best for Established Bricks-and-Mortar

Tyro is Australia’s only bank-grade independent EFTPOS provider. Unlike Stripe and Square (US companies), Tyro is an Australian business regulated by APRA as a licensed bank. That matters for compliance-conscious industries like healthcare, legal, and accounting.

Pricing

• Card present rate: from 1.4% (negotiable based on volume)
• Terminal rental: from A$29/month (or purchase outright)
• No lock-in contracts on month-to-month plans
• Integrated surcharging: pass fees to customers automatically if you choose

Note: Tyro pricing is customised based on your business type and monthly volume: the rates above are indicative starting points. Request a quote directly from Tyro for your specific situation.

What Tyro Does Well

• Bank-grade reliability: regulated by APRA, Australian-owned and operated
• 800+ POS integrations: connects with major Australian POS systems including Lightspeed, Vend, Kounta, Impos, and more
• Health provider billing. Medicare and private health fund claiming built in (unique to Tyro)
• Business loans. Tyro offers merchant cash advances based on your payment history
• Next business day settlement: faster than most competitors
• Dedicated Australian support: phone support included

Where Tyro Falls Short

• In-person only. Tyro doesn’t support online payments; you’d need a separate gateway for e-commerce
• Terminal required: monthly rental fee adds to ongoing costs
• Slower setup: approval process takes longer than Square or Stripe (it’s a licensed bank)
• No free tier: always has a cost, even at low volumes

Best For

Established retail, hospitality, healthcare practices (especially for Medicare/health fund claiming), tradies, professional services: any business doing consistent in-person volume that values Australian support and reliability.

Fee Comparison: What Do You Actually Pay?

Let’s run the numbers on a business processing A$10,000/month in card payments:

Estimates only. Tyro rates are negotiated; actual Stripe costs depend on transaction size. Always get a direct quote.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Stripe if:

• You sell primarily online or have an e-commerce store
• You run a subscription or SaaS business
• You need deep integrations or have a developer on hand
• International customers are a meaningful part of your revenue

Choose Square if:

• You’re a café, restaurant, market stall, or pop-up
• You want a free POS system with no monthly fees
• You’re just starting out and want simple, predictable pricing
• You want one ecosystem for payments, bookings, and loyalty

Choose Tyro if:

• You’re an established bricks-and-mortar business with consistent volume
• You run a medical, dental, or allied health practice (Medicare claiming)
• You want Australian support and a regulated, local provider
• You need deep integration with your existing POS system

Can You Use More Than One?

Yes: and many Australian businesses do. A common setup:

• Stripe for the online store and recurring subscriptions
• Square or Tyro for in-person payments at the shopfront

There’s no rule that says you can only pick one. Just make sure your accounting software (Xero, MYOB) can reconcile both feeds without creating a reporting nightmare.

Bottom Line

All three are solid, legitimate platforms used by thousands of Australian businesses. The right choice comes down to where you sell:

• Online-first? → Stripe
• Face-to-face, starting out? → Square
• Established in-person with volume? → Tyro

Related: AI Tools for E-Commerce Businesses in Australia | ServiceM8: The Darwin App Used by 50,000 Australian Tradies (2026 Review)

If you’re unsure, Square’s free plan is the lowest-risk way to start: you can always switch or add Stripe later as your online presence grows.

Sources

• Stripe Australia Pricing
• Square Australia Payments
• Tyro EFTPOS & Payments
• APRA. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Stripe or Square better for Australian small business?

Square is better for businesses with a physical presence: it offers free card readers and integrated POS. Stripe is better for online-first businesses and developers who need API flexibility. Tyro is the strongest option for hospitality and retail businesses wanting direct integration with Australian POS systems.

Does Stripe work in Australia?

Yes. Stripe is fully operational in Australia and supports AUD transactions, Australian bank accounts, and local payment methods. Processing fees are 1.7% + AU$0.30 for domestic cards. Stripe is widely used by Australian e-commerce businesses and SaaS companies.

What payment terminal fees does Tyro charge in Australia?

Tyro charges a flat transaction fee rather than a percentage: fees vary by card type and business volume but are typically competitive with the major banks. Tyro also rents terminals rather than requiring purchase, which reduces upfront costs. Contact Tyro directly for current pricing as rates are negotiated based on business volume.

📊 Compare AI tools side by side | 💼 Free resources & AI prompt packs

Looking for more comparisons? Browse all our Best-Of guides for Australian small business →